November 25, 2006

Health Care in a Thailand International Hospital Versus Health Care in the USA: The only difference is the difference between night and day
I (Mark's Mom) once worked as an office nurse for Dr. Tom Masters in Springfield, Illinois. A better doctor never existed. We actually ran our appointments on time. He studied each medicine a new patient was on to determine if the patient benefited from it or not and made certain that each client from the governor and the CEOs whose physicals we did to our elderly nursing home clients and the guys in the jail he and I visited got what they needed and were well informed about their health status and needs. Occasionally, a new client would ask a question like: " Doctor, it wouldn't make any difference if I did "x" instead of the "y" you are suggesting, would it?" Doctor Masters would get a serious expression on his face and peer down at the client and say: "The only difference would be the difference between north and south." That expression comes to mind as I think about the care Mark received at Bumrungrad International Hospital in Bangkok compared to the care he is getting and will likely get at the VA hospital and the care reported to me by friends including nurse friends.

I have to ask "What has happened to nursing (as well as health care) in this country?" The Thai nurses seem 100% compassionate, caring, respectful and always ready to help you. Your IV monitor beeps and you don't have to ring a bell. The nurse or aide comes to fix it. Far too many American nurses give the impression they are way too busy to help anyone, even in situations where I see them chatting with each other and moving at a snail's pace. Recently, when Mark had waited way past his appointment time and been begging to lie down at the VA, a nurse implied he could not be in pain as his blood pressure was not up. Doesn't morphine and compazine lower blood pressure and isn't it possible other factors allow a patient to be in pain without elevated blood pressure? A while later , I asked the nurse if she could estimate how long before Mark would be seen. She said: "I think you can have too much information." Mark finally solved his need to lie down to get relief from pain in his chest due to tissue and bone damage from the chest wall tumor and 15 very recent radiation treatments. He went out into the hall and laid down on the floor. This action caused a flurry of activity and produced a place to lie down in the treatment room. His appointment was at 9 and he was told he must not report in later than 8:30 sharp. He saw the doctors at 12:30 and I must say the doctors were exceedingly respectful and compassionate as were some nurses in the treatment room. By the time Mark left the oncology clinic and waited in line at the pharmacy three times and waited until his number came up to wait in line, it was 4:30 when we left the VA: a long day for a very sick young man who still had to ride the 3 and a half hours back to Austin.

Other stories of nursing care in Austin Texas and elsewhere: After thyroid surgery in Austin, a friend reports that she rang the bell for pain medication. She could not talk above a whisper due to swelling from surgery. The person at the desk said: "Speak up. We can't help you if you don't speak up." No one was sent to check on the patient and pain medication was a long time in coming. Another nurse friend on vacation recently in Colorado had an occluded ureter and could not urinate and was in pain. She reported that the emergency room staff treated her as if she were a drug seeking addict. The nurse who catheterized her, took only a specimen and did not empty the bladder. When asked why she had not emptied the bladder since the patient was unable to urinate and was uncomfortable, the nurse offered to do another catheterization. There also seems to be a rash of people falling off of guerneys or being dropped in transfer from guerney to bed . The hospital staff often say they are way too busy and too overworked to help a patient especially with something like getting a tooth brush out for someone told not to get out of bed after surgery. I had this experience in an Austin Hospital. "Everyone is busy and can't help you." Why did I find this hard to believe when after asking for a hour for the tooth brush whenever someone came into the room, one nursing assistant who was too busy to help me, spent a long time telling me that she had bought a farm and all about the farm and then asked if she could have my potted plant if I didn't want it. A social worker wandered in eventually and got the tooth brushing equipment for me. How can nursing education and nursing texts and journals in the USA claim the nursing profession is still all about compassion, caring, thorough head to toe assessments, and holistic nursing when nurses and nurse's assistants today are "way too busy and overworked to listen to and attend to client's needs "? Today in the USA you never know if you will get a compassionate, caring, competent nurse or a Miss Rachet behave-alike from One Flew Over the CooCoo's Nest or something in between. What's your opinion? I invite comments/stories from anyone who agrees and from those who don't. Your thoughts are important!
PS FROM MARK - "So sorry that I can't answer e-mail right now. I am trying to get the pain under control and get some healing of my chest. When I am able, I will e-mail you all. Thanks for all your support. It means everything to me. " Mark

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

You should write some news articles on this! I think we have grown complacent- we accept this type of bad treatment because we buy into the idea that the nurses are too busy, rather than asking why the hospital doesn't hire more. The health care industry is a money-making industry and they are doing well... they should treat their patients (customers) well, too. If we lose sight of what that good treatment looks like, then it will only continue to get worse.

Anonymous said...

It's money, pure and simple (hi Mark, this is John Taylor from Yokosuka. Finally got off my butt and decided to type you a HULLO). My grandfather was diagnosed with lung cancer on (roundabout) Jan. 10, 1999. He was dead within 2 weeks. For the first few days he was at the VA hospital and it was a cattle market. Think Nurse Ratchet from One Flew Over. Patient care was okay...okay if this was 16th century Mongolia.

I said to my grandma "wait a minute, aren't you guys pumping mucho dollars into some healthcare plan?" We inquired, and they moved him from the VA in Durham, NC., across the street to the Duke University Cancer Center. It was like night and day, as you said. My grandfather sneezed, and two nurses were there with ivory-plated kleenex. The difference? In the latter case my grandfather used his health insurance to move him over. Before, he was just another ex-WWII guy nearing the end of his life.

In any event, US healthcare still leaves a great deal to be desired. I hope you get some better TLC. What works with my family is raising the Almighty Cain when things aren't acceptable. Scream at the supervisor, then scream at that supervisor's supervisor. But you both are veterans at this so I'm pretty much preaching to the choir here.

Take care, Mark. I mean that.